| 1. | Originality. Are there entries in the PUMAS Collection, or other common sources you might know, that seem to duplicate this contribution? |
| 2. | Accuracy of Content. (Any errors?) |
| 3. | Is the presentation clear? If not, could you specify what you found confusing. Is the context explained adequately? |
| 4. | To what grade level is the material appropriate? |
| 4a. | Choose one: Easy, Moderate, Advanced -- at this Grade Level. |
| 5. | Any suggestions for changes in the Curriculum Topic Benchmarks? |
| 6. | Any suggestions for changes to the Subject Keywords? |
| 7. | Any comments on the length or format of the contribution? |
| 8. | Any copy-editing suggestions? (grammar, spelling, phrasing) |
| 8a. | Check here if you are sending an annotated manuscript. |
| 9. | Any further comments or suggestions? |
| 10. | Overall Recommendation (pick one): Accept, Return to Author for Revision, Reject |
|
Back to PUMAS Home PageLast update: Friday April 5, 2002 PUMAS Editor: Ralph Kahn WebCurator: Cecelia Lawshe URL: http://pumas.jpl.nasa.gov/ participants/Reviewer_Questions.html Copyright: © 1996, California Institute of Technology Privacy Statement ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Based on U.S. Government sponsored research |